I read this review of the Kansas City Chiefs post-Zeldman redesign a while ago when it first came out, but I re-read it today to see all of the comments it got. The blogger slams the Chiefs for replacing a happy, valid, web standards design with one built on Flash and more nested tables than you could shake a blink tag at.
I revisited it because I mentioned the Chiefs’ site the other day when summarizing the history of Blogsmith. I knew they were still using the same publishing system that Dave and I built, just with a new design that fits in more with the rest of the NFL and angering standardistas. The CMS was customizable enough to handle all kinds of designs — valid or not.
My favorite gripe in there was this one:
Aw, you had me at “jackholes.”
I’m pretty sure that all of the NFL video is in Real format, so the Chiefs had no choice in the matter.
In the comments, they quote a really defensive email from Lance, who runs the site. That’s funny, since the Chiefs aren’t known for defense. (Zing! I couldn’t help myself.)
I know Lance and he’s a pretty good guy. I know Jeffrey and he’s one of the nicest guys I’ve ever worked with.
It’s admirable that this blogger is giving the Chiefs grief for parting ways with Zeldman and for taking a giant step backwards in their standards support, but to be fair, the Chiefs won like 13 games in a row the year before they redesigned with Zeldman and then had a losing season after the switch.
I would have redesigned and ditched web standards myself.